1808-Robert Culbertson.-This text is a collection of letters written by Robert Culbertson of Leith in 1808, responding to criticisms from Rev. Mr. Chalmers. The work addresses theological disputes within the Secession Church, particularly regarding the “Old-Light” and “New-Light” principles. Culbertson defends his position against Chalmers’ accusations of blasphemy, misrepresentation, and other personal attacks. The letters also include appendices with additional observations and extracts from religious documents. The publication reflects the intense theological debates and personal rivalries within Scottish religious communities during this period, focusing on issues like the role of civil magistrates in religious matters, church discipline, and interpretations of covenants and testimonies.
Read More
1800-Robert Culbertson.-In “A Vindication of the Principles of Seceders, upon the Head of Occasional Communion” (1800), Robert Culbertson presents a rigorous theological defense of the Seceder position against occasional communion with churches from which they had separated. Culbertson argues that such communion would be inconsistent with the grounds of their separation, undermine steadfastness in maintaining their Christian profession, compromise their role as witnesses for the present truth, and potentially harm both themselves and the churches they had left. He contends that the Seceders’ existence as a distinct body would lose its purpose if they were to freely communicate with churches whose principles contradicted their own. Culbertson addresses numerous objections, including appeals to Christ’s example, the presence of godly individuals in other churches, and the original intentions of the first Seceders, countering each with scriptural and logical arguments. The work exemplifies Culbertson’s scholarly approach and his commitment to maintaining the integrity of the Secession testimony during a period of significant ecclesiastical division in Scotland.
Read More